Facebook Evidence Order

home | law articles | facebook evidence order

Facebook privacy rights defense by Ken Rosenfeld, California Criminal Defense Attorney Next Article

California chief justice blocks Facebook evidence order 

Sacramento, California - chief justice blocks Facebook evidence order - criminal defense attorney

At least temporarily, California Supreme Court Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye blocked a Sacramento judge Monday from forcing a juror to turn over his Facebook postings from a recent gang beating trial. 

The chief justice issued the one-paragraph stay order until the full court takes up the issue on its merits.

Kenneth L. Rosenfeld, said he was “thrilled” by Cantil-Sakauye’s decision. “This decision will protect the rights of everybody who uses social media from having their privacy invaded,” Rosenfeld said.

Defense lawyers in the Killa Mobb case are asking for a new trial based on the disclosure of the juror’s alleged misconduct.

They asked to review the juror’s postings to see if he was biased during the trial or if any of the responses from his friends to what he had written may have influenced his decision-making during the trial.

Five reputed members of the gang who were convicted in the beating of a man in an Arden Fair-area gas station are awaiting sentencing in the case.

Mike Wise, the attorney for one of the defendants, called the stay order “procedural” and predicted “a quick turnaround” by the full Supreme Court.

Facebook had said it is precluded by federal computer privacy law from turning over the postings on its own and that the company needed either a search warrant, a court order or the consent of the user before it would make them available to the court.